Friday, May 6, 2011

"Diary of a Wimpy Kid" by Jeff Kinney

I chose to review this book because this series has been so popular over the last several years.

Diary of a Wimpy Kid
Author & Illustrator: Jeff Kinney
Genre: Realistic Fiction
Age Level: 10-13 years

SUMMARY
Greg Heffley keeps a journal of his experiences during one year of middle school. Through Greg's voice and cartoon drawings, we get a glimpse of the drama and traumas of middle school life. He has to learn how to deal with many things from having a best friend who isn't very cool to having parents who he thinks are a bit too strict. In his quest for a place to fit in, Greg tries running for Treasurer, he tries out for the school play, he tries being a safety patrol, and he tries for the cartoonist job in the school paper. Greg experiences the humiliations of a wrestling unit in gym class as well as being picked on by high school students.

CRITIQUE
Many of the reviews I read interpreted Greg as a basically good kid who is oblivious to his faults. Supposedly that's the basis of the humor.  I did not interpret Greg's character that way and, therefore, thought he was very offensive. Greg is selfish, unkind (to his younger brother), disloyal (to his friend Rowley), deceitful (to parents and teachers), and cowardly. He is a very unappealing character. As I read, I continued to hope that Greg would to do something to redeem himself, but he does not.

The bottom line is that I would NOT want my child to read this book. There is far better literature available. If you are looking specifically for a story about a boy who often gets into scrapes, I would recommend Henry Huggins by Beverly Cleary. He is not "perfect" but at least he is a well-intentioned and honorable character.

RATINGS
Disrespectful/Bad Attitude: Heavy
Frightening/Suspenseful: None
Profanity: Mild
Sex: Mild
Substance Use: Mild
Mature Themes: None
Violence: Moderate

SPECIFIC CONTENT
Disrespectful/Bad Attitude:
-Greg's advice is to "set people's expectations real low so you end up surprising them by practically doing nothing at all."
-Pulls pranks on his best friend, Rowley.
-General, and constant, complaining about his parents and their style of parenting.
-Deceives his father by running through the sprinkler to make himself look sweaty when, in reality, he has been playing video games at his friend's house.
-Sneaks downstairs at night to listen to music that is forbidden.
-Greg kicks over his younger brother's toys while he is playing with them.
-Tricks Rowley's father into letting them play a video game by switching the case.
-Makes campaign posters disrespecting his opponent.
-Refuses to sing during school play. Throws apples at girl instead.
-Forces younger brother to eat a pretend spider.
-Writes a form letter for his thank-you notes.
-Greg makes fun of Rowley's father.
-Kicks over his younger brother's snowman.
-Hides some other kids' comics under a pile of papers on the teacher's desk so they won't be considered for the cartoonist job.
-Greg chases kindergartners (for whom he is responsible) with a worm. Lets Rowley take the blame. Tells his mom he did the right thing and lets her take him out for ice cream as a reward.
-Acts nicely toward Rowley just so that he will be invited to Six Flags.

Profanity:
-Jerk, sissy, stupid, morons, nerd, dumb, runt, dork, poop, idiot, and fart are some of the words used.
-Boys in independent study make a list of all the swear words they know, but you don't see them.
-Greg listens to his older brother's music that is labeled with a parent advisory for language. Again, you don't hear any of it.

Sex:
-Roderick has a magazine that shows a girl in a bikini draped over the hood of a car. Roderick gets in trouble when his younger brother, Manny, takes it to day care for show and tell.

Substance Use:
-The school has an anti-smoking poster contest. The boy who wins, according to Greg, smokes at least one pack of cigarettes every day.

Violence:
-Kids are shown being bullied (e.g. punched, tripped, shoved, kicked) at school.
-Greg hits Rowley in the face as a joke.
-Boys practice professional wrestling moves on each other at school.
-Boys throw apples at a girl and knock her glasses off during a school play.
-Greg breaks Rowley's hand playing a dangerous game.
-Comic shows skater boy having head sliced off by telephone wire.
-Kids throw snowballs at each other.
-High school boys force Rowley to eat something disgusting off the playground.